GDP report reveals ominous Great Depression warning sign not seen since 1932

GDP report reveals ominous Great Depression warning sign not seen since 1932

The newest numbers from the Bureau of Economic Analysis present that the U.S. economy grew by 2.9 % within the fourth quarter of final yr, and a pair of.1 % for 2022. While the White House was fast to take credit score for the state of the nation’s financial system, they may need to suppose twice. This newest report ought to have alarm bells ringing, not trumpets sounding.

That’s as a result of financial progress is slowing down. Even the areas which contributed positively to gross home product (GDP) are not essentially indicators of prosperity. For instance, business investment grew at only one.4 % within the fourth quarter, however that was nearly completely stock progress. Nonresidential funding, a key driver of future financial progress, was up simply 0.7 %.

Meanwhile, residential funding fell off a cliff, dropping 26.7 % as shoppers have been unable to afford the mixture of excessive residence costs, excessive rates of interest and falling actual incomes. No marvel homeownership affordability has fallen to the bottom degree in that metric’s historical past.


But the expansion in inventories, which accounted for half the GDP progress within the fourth quarter, is not a superb sign, both. It is the results of companies being unable to unload current inventories at present costs. Liquidating that stock at reductions will imply decrease income, an extra drag on future progress.

Another optimistic contributor to the GDP quantity was net exports, which is solely exports minus imports. But the achieve right here resulted from a slowdown in worldwide commerce — hardly a sign of wealth for Americans. Instead, imports are merely falling sooner than exports, which reveals up as a rise in GDP.

The most troubling info within the GDP report is the precipitous drop in actual disposable revenue, which fell over $1 trillion in 2022. For context, that is the second-largest share drop in actual disposable revenue ever, behind solely 1932, the worst yr of the Great Depression.

To see why, think about your hours have been reduce at work. You’re now incomes $100 much less per week, so that you resolve to scale back your weekly spending by $105. Your finances then reveals a web enhance of $5 left over on the finish of the week. Your earnings are like exports, your spending like imports and the general change to your finances is like web exports.

So, though you might be worse off, simply going by the change to your finances, you look like higher off. That is strictly what occurred with web exports within the GDP report.


But maybe most troubling is the precipitous drop in real disposable income, which fell over $1 trillion in 2022.

For context, that is the second-largest share drop in actual disposable revenue ever, behind solely 1932, the worst yr of the Great Depression. To sustain with inflation, shoppers are depleting their financial savings and burning by way of the “stimulus” checks they acquired throughout 2020 and 2021. Credit card debt continues rising, whereas financial savings plummeted $1.6 trillion final yr, falling beneath 2009 ranges.

As shoppers proceed depleting money reserves and borrowing prices are rising, the expansion in client spending will preserve slowing. Since that accounts for roughly two-thirds of GDP, this doesn’t bode effectively for the financial system.

Just how a lot ache is the patron feeling? The common household has misplaced about $6,000 in annual purchasing power beneath Biden as a result of costs have risen a lot sooner than wages. Higher rates of interest have elevated annual borrowing prices by $1,400, in order that the common household successfully has $7,400 much less of their annual finances. 


But that’s simply the common. Someone attempting to purchase a median priced residence at the moment could have a month-to-month mortgage cost that’s 80 % larger than when Biden took office. That means spending an additional $9,500 a yr for a similar home. It’s no marvel individuals are financially strapped and taking up second or third jobs on this financial system.

Meanwhile, federal nondefense spending grew 11.2 % within the fourth quarter, one other instance of politicians feeding the federal finances whereas ravenous the household finances.


If you’ve ever pushed a automotive that ran out of gasoline, you could have seen the engine rev up proper earlier than stalling out. That appears to be what we’re witnessing with the financial system — an engine working on fumes, about to cease. 

The final thing America wants is extra taxing, spending and regulation by the federal authorities. Instead, we have to observe the successful method laid out by President Ronald Reagan and Fed Chair Paul Volcker, which introduced the financial system again from stagflation. 

Reagan scaled again authorities whereas Volcker stopped the financial manipulation and allowed rates of interest to hunt their pure degree. 

Let’s hope we don’t must relearn that lesson — as a result of the tutoring on the college of life isn’t low-cost.

E. J. Antoni is a analysis fellow at The Heritage Foundation’s Center for Data Analysis and a senior fellow at Committee to Unleash Prosperity.